Under almost every Dota 2 patch recap there is a comment that begins with "Actually, they also changed..." and ends with a confident claim. Some of those comments are right and useful. Many are half-remembered. For a long time I treated the top comment as an extension of the video, and a few games went worse because of it. These days comments get their own small procedure.

A comment is a pointer, not a proof

I read comments after I have watched the video and after I have read the official notes, never before. If a comment mentions a change I did not see in either place, I treat it as a pointer. It tells me which hero or item name to search for in the official text, and that is all it does.

A hero on a grassy forest clearing next to a green creature and curved spikes on the Dota 2 map

Dota 2 screenshot — © Valve, official Steam store page.

Three kinds of replies I skip at once

Replies that say "trust me, I play this hero every day" are the first. Replies that quote numbers without saying where they come from are the second. Replies that argue with each other about which version is meant are the third. In all three cases nothing can be checked, so I leave them where they are.

The one kind I keep

A reply that quotes a sentence from the notes in full is worth my minute. I search for that sentence, and if I find it, the reply becomes a normal note in my own words. If I cannot find it, I write the reply down on the right side of my notes with a date and let it expire after a week.

Why I do not argue

I do not answer comments with corrections. I do not know the person, and the video's author is not asking me for fact-checking. My own notes are the place where I keep what I trust, and they are private, so nobody has to lose an argument.

The filter I use for the video itself

Before I let a comment affect my play, I make sure the video passed the same quick filter I apply to every recap. It is described in a note about four quick checks before spending twenty minutes on a video, and comments simply go through a shorter version of it.